TODAY: Scottish parliament to debate the Rural Economy and Connectivity (REC) committee report on salmon farming
Legislative impact is expected to follow on from today's debate, Wednesday 6th February 2019, for which S&TCS have contributed the following briefing:
S&TCS salmon farming debate briefing
S&TCS concerns concentrate on the proven negative effects of salmon and rainbow trout farming at sea on wild salmonids - both Atlantic salmon and sea trout. It has been clear for many years that Scotland’s performance, particularly on sea lice, falls very far short of the internationally agreed NASCO goals.
As a bare minimum S&TCS wishes to see the following five changes in Scotland, all of which were supported by both REC and ECCLR Committees:
- The development and introduction of full closed containment farming.
- The clear identification of a Scottish public authority charged with the statutory function to protect wild fish from the negative interactions of fish farming.
- No expansion of the industry while wild fish interactions remain uncontrolled.
- Relocation of existing sensitive sites.
- Full transparency and publication of sea lice, escapes, mortalities and disease information.
The Scottish Government response is in danger of allowing the “status quo”, in terms of the regulation and legislation of salmon farms (and transparency in the way that the industry operates), to persist for the foreseeable future.
This would be in stark contrast to what the ECCLR and REC Committees have both advocated after exhaustive examination and consideration. Both Committees identified major shortcomings in the way that the industry is permitted to operate. Action to remedy matters, rather than further prolonged discussion, must now be the priority.
Read the S&TCS briefing in full:
Background: 2018 Rec Committee report
The REC committee report was published in November 2018, following the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform (ECCLR) committee report.
Both 2018 Parliamentary inquires into salmon farming, as conducted by the ECCLR and REC Committees, were triggered by S&TCS’ formal Petition to the Scottish Parliament’s Petitions Committee in 2016.
The 148-page REC report found that urgent action was needed to improve the regulation of the Scottish salmon farming industry and to address fish health and environmental challenges. Commenting on the REC report in November, Andrew Graham-Stewart, Director of S&TCS, said:
“We applaud the REC Committee’s report, which cuts through many years of Scottish Government and industry spin and prevarication.
The onus is now on Scottish Government to act without delay to implement the Report’s recommendations, giving wild fish much needed protection from sea lice and diseases emanating from salmon farms”.
S&TCS look to the Scottish Government to take action today.